Youth unemployment and the structural divide: What the Milburn Review means for North East schools

More than one in five young people in the North East are not in education, employment or training. A major new review sets out ambitious plans to change this, but Schools North East warns that schools cannot be held responsible for inequalities beyond their control.
The Milburn Review, From a Welfare State to a Working State sets out wide-ranging recommendations to tackle youth unemployment, including expanded apprenticeships, stronger employment support, changes to the benefits system and new expectations for schools.
While we welcome the review’s recognition that young people’s prospects are shaped by education, health, employment opportunities and the wider economy, its proposals also raise important questions about school accountability, particularly in regions where the structural divide continues to limit opportunities.
The North East’s youth unemployment challenge
According to the North East Evidence Hub, 20.4% of 16–24-year-olds in the North East were not in education, employment or training (NEET) in 2025, compared with 13.5% across England.
That represents approximately 61,700 young people, with the regional NEET rate rising by 6.9 percentage points over five years, compared with 1.5 percentage points nationally.
The review sets an ambition to reduce the national NEET rate to approximately 5% by 2036, although its modelling suggests the proposed reforms would reduce it to 6.8%.
Research from the Sutton Trust’s Crossing Paths report further highlights the geographical divide in young people’s opportunities. Just 35% of young people in Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West made a successful transition into education, employment or apprenticeships after GCSEs, compared with 81% in the highest-performing areas.
Only 13% of disadvantaged pupils in the North East progressed to A Levels, compared with 34% in London.
These differences reflect the wider structural divide that Schools North East has consistently highlighted: inequalities in transport, employment, health services and access to opportunities that shape young people’s futures long before they enter the labour market.
What does the Milburn Review propose for schools?
Among the review’s recommendations and ambitions are:
- A new Ready-for-Work Standard, inspected by Ofsted, alongside published school performance measures linked to pupils’ destinations after leaving education.
- Additional assessments at Key Stage 3, greater curriculum flexibility and a stronger focus on work experience.
- Ambitions for 90% of five-year-olds to be school-ready and 90% of pupils to meet the expected standard in literacy and numeracy at the end of primary school by 2036.
- Expanded further education and apprenticeship opportunities, alongside stronger employment support and proposals for a guarantee of education or employment opportunities.
- Changes to the benefits system for under-25s, intended to support more young people into education and work.
Improving pathways into employment is welcome, but Schools North East is concerned that some proposals could introduce additional accountability pressures without recognising what schools can reasonably influence.
A young person’s employment prospects depend on the availability of local jobs, accessible transport, suitable training and health support. These are factors that individual schools cannot control.
Schools should be judged on the quality of education and support they provide, not the strength of the local labour market their former pupils enter.
This concern is particularly relevant to Ofsted’s renewed inspection framework.
Our latest Ofsted research, Inspection in Practice: Inspection in Practice: North East schools and the Structural Divide, draws on evidence from school and trust leaders across the region and raises important questions about whether inspection adequately recognises disadvantage, inclusion and school context.
The Milburn Review’s proposals risk adding further measures of success without resolving these existing concerns.
Read our Ofsted inspection research
Creating opportunities beyond the school gates
The review’s recommendations to expand further education and apprenticeships offer potential benefits for the North East, particularly if they improve access to high-quality vocational routes and local employment.
However, additional training places will have limited impact if young people cannot reach them or if suitable jobs remain unavailable.
Reform must also recognise the needs of young people with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND), including access to appropriate training, employment support and essential services. Changes to the benefits system must not leave vulnerable young people without the support they need.
The same principle applies to the review’s ambitions for earlier intervention, including improving school readiness and attainment. These goals require investment in early years provision, family support and specialist services, particularly in communities experiencing long-term disadvantage.
Meanwhile, schools are already responding to substantial changes across SEND, curriculum and inspection. Any further responsibilities must come with realistic funding, workforce capacity and sufficient time to implement them.
As Schools North East has repeatedly argued, schools cannot be expected to compensate indefinitely for gaps in the wider system.
A chance to address the structural divide
Chris Zarraga, Director of Schools North East, said: “The North East is full of talented and ambitious young people, but their opportunities are too often shaped by where they grow up. Our schools work tirelessly to prepare young people for their futures, yet they cannot create jobs or the wider opportunities their communities need.
“The Milburn Review offers an important opportunity to address youth unemployment, but the government must recognise that this is about more than qualifications, benefits or individual ambition. It is about tackling the structural divide that continues to limit the life chances of young people in our region.
“Young people in the North East deserve the same opportunities to succeed as their peers elsewhere in the country. That requires sustained investment in our communities, not simply placing greater expectations on schools and young people.”
Schools North East is calling for a coordinated response across education, employment, health and regional economic policy, with investment directed towards communities facing the greatest barriers.
As Schools North East looks ahead to 2027, the challenge of turning national policy ambitions into meaningful improvements for our region remains central to our work.
This will be a key consideration at our Academies Conference 2027, From Mission to Impact, on Thursday 21 January, where school and trust leaders will come together to explore the future of education and the changes needed to improve outcomes for North East pupils.
Find out more about our Academies Conference 2027
The Milburn Review has the potential to improve opportunities for young people across the country. But for those growing up in the North East, meaningful change will depend on whether the government tackles the structural inequalities shaping their futures, rather than simply holding schools accountable for their consequences.